It begins with a flag, a fanfare, and an attempt to convince us that this matters. Captain America: Brave New World is Marvel’s latest shot in the locker, and it lands… somewhere very far from the target. This is not a brave new world. It’s the old one, wrapped in CGI and dialogue so flat you start missing the ad break.
One star
Two stars
Three stars
Four stars
Five stars
Disclaimer: Apropos Magazine received access or a review copy. As always, we share our own impressions — unfiltered.
Six stars
So. Anthony Mackie is the new Captain America. He really does try. That has to count for something. But it feels a bit like watching someone try to breathe life into an inflatable boat with a hole in it — using their mouth. There’s no spark, no weight, and, most importantly, nothing you actually want to care about.
The plot? Something about threats to the world order, a new enemy with murky motives, and a whole lot of talk about freedom, responsibility, and big decisions. All of it delivered with the kind of solemn lines where you can almost hear the screenwriter’s PowerPoint in the background: “Here, the audience should feel something.”
Action without a soul
Of course there’s action. Plenty of it. Explosions, planes, slow-motion fights in the rain. You’ve seen it before. And you have, because Marvel has developed a kind of copy-paste formula that makes even the most grandiose scenes feel like watching someone press a button. There’s no energy, no rhythm — just collisions without consequence.
The acting: everyone is here, but no one is present
Mackie wrestles with a role that doesn’t know whether it wants to be politically relevant, moving, or just superhero-cool. Harrison Ford turns up as General Thaddeus Ross and looks like a man who would rather be anywhere else than in this script. The rest of the cast are just as blurred as the characters’ motivations. You don’t believe it. And worse still — you don’t even want to believe it.
What happened to Marvel’s magic?
Brave New World is symptomatic of Marvel’s latest crisis: there’s plenty of noise, but no substance. It’s as if they’ve lost their feel for what made the universe compelling in the first place. Characters with inner conflict. Villains with depth. Moments that stayed in your body afterwards. Instead, we get a film that looks like a trailer that never becomes anything.
Verdict:
A new world? No. Just the old one, without charm, without energy, without meaning. Captain America: Brave New World is what Marvel makes when they forget why they started.
1 out of 5 Apropos stars. Because we can’t give zero.
